A choose has dominated in favour of defence who argued that Filip Grkovski can solely be discovered responsible of legal negligence and impaired operation inflicting loss of life and bodily hurt, if the crown has confirmed past an affordable doubt that Grkovski was driving the boat on the time of a tragic crash on Could thirty first, 2022.
Superior Courtroom Justice P. Tamara Sugunasiri made her ruling upfront of closing arguments on the judge-alone trial for the Mississauga man charged with impaired operation and legal negligence inflicting loss of life and bodily hurt.
24-year-old Megan Wu and 34-year-old Julio Abrantes each drowned after Grkovski’s boat struck rocks off Tommy Thompson Park close to the Outer Harbour Marina inflicting the boat to flip over. 4 passengers had been rescued from the cabin of the vessel, 4 others swam to security however Wu and Abrantes had been trapped underneath the boat and couldn’t be saved.
Defence lawyer Alan Gold advised courtroom that there’s affordable doubt that Grkovski was driving on the time of the tragic occasion.
A passenger named Eddie Denkha testified for the crown that Grkovski was working the boat on the time of the collision however Grkovski who took the witness stand in his personal defence and pointed the finger at Denkha.
No different passengers might say who was driving the 3o foot pleasure craft on the time of the collision.
Gold advised Sugunasiri that Denkha was “precisely the sort who one who would drive dangerously” given Denkha has a related legal document for harmful driving and “a horrendous freeway site visitors act document for the sort of conduct that occurred to trigger this tragedy.”
Get every day Nationwide information
Get the day’s high information, political, financial, and present affairs headlines, delivered to your inbox as soon as a day.
The defence identified that simply previous to the collision, one of many witnesses testified that Denkha had been driving and he or she advised him to decelerate. Gold mentioned that Denkha additionally modified his story about what he mentioned Filip did. “In his interview, he advised police he was going too quick … to decelerate. However at trial, he mentioned that Filip drove too near shore,” Gold defined.
Gold referred to as Denkha’s testimony “a lie” and argued he was both exhibiting off for Wu whom he was romantically considering or testing out the pace of the boat.
Gold mentioned his consumer went beneath deck to spend time together with his girlfriend, arising twice and on the second time, it was too late, Denkha had prompted the accident.
“The tragedy befell nevertheless it’s all on Eddie. It’s not on my consumer,” Gold concluded.
Assistant crown lawyer Jordan Howard argued that Grkovski’s testimony shouldn’t believed. Howard identified that the accused was unwilling to reply sure questions and quite a lot of occasions, gave proof that was contradicted by others
“Particularly in regards to the argument together with his girlfriend. One of many causes he shouldn’t be believed is as a result of he was downplaying the arguing, and his proof was contradicts nearly everybody,” mentioned Howard.
Howard identified Grkovski additionally denied there was use of cocaine on the boat, regardless of what others mentioned, Grkovski downplayed Denkha’s intoxication and testified he advised everybody the place the life jackets had been on the boat. Not one of the passengers testified they knew the place the life jackets had been besides one girl who had been on the boat earlier than.
As for Denkha’s testimony, Howard mentioned even when her honour disblieves him, there’s different proof past an affordable doubt that Grkovski was behind the wheel on the time of the crash.
Concerning impairment, the prosecutor mentioned on the time of the crash, toxicology experiences discovered Grkovski had over 80 mg/100 ml of alcohol in his blood. On the problem of legal negligence, Howard identified quite a lot of elements main as much as the crash that confirmed a wanton disregard for the folks on the boat.
“Impairment, pace, lack of security gear, these all signify cumulatively a marked and substantial departure from what an affordable particular person would have performed,” mentioned Howard. “In the event you imagine he was driving the boat, then you must resolve he was criminally negligent on the time.”
Sugunasiri will ship her judgement till Could twentieth.
© 2025 World Information, a division of Corus Leisure Inc.
Source link