A controversial decision by a rural Manitoba college division to deliver again the singing of “God Save the King” every morning has some neighborhood members scratching their heads.
At a board assembly on Monday evening, Mountain View School Division stated the plan — which seems to be primarily based on an obscure piece of provincial laws that has all however disappeared from apply provincewide — will go forward whereas the division consults with legal professionals on any authorized repercussions.
Fabien Carriere, who has three kids at faculties within the division, advised International Winnipeg he feels the scenario isn’t solely a waste of time and assets, but in addition a “slap within the face” to the massive inhabitants of Indigenous college students who attend Mountain View faculties.
“I believe the quantity of effort and time being spent by the board of trustees on this problem is a waste of time and, for my part as a Metis citizen, it’s a step backwards towards fact and reconciliation,” stated Carriere, who attended Mountain View faculties himself from kindergarten by Grade 12.
“The varsity division has greater issues to fret about than singing a tune each morning.”
“There’s a ton of Indigenous college students on this college division, and I actually don’t suppose that there’s any actual goal in singing it. The one time I’ve sang, ‘God Save the King’ is at a Remembrance Day service, and that’s the place it belongs, it doesn’t belong within the faculties,” he stated.
The division has been a lightning rod for controversy since final spring, when a school trustee’s comments about residential faculties led to broad condemnation and a assessment by the province.
Get every day Nationwide information
Get the day’s prime information, political, financial, and present affairs headlines, delivered to your inbox as soon as a day.
That trustee’s remarks at a board assembly, reportedly suggesting residential faculties began out as a very good factor, could have not directly led to the dismissal of the Dauphin-area college division’s superintendent and the following resignation of three different trustees — finally requiring the provincial authorities to step in and appoint a special advisory panel.
In an announcement Wednesday, Mountain View board chair Jason Gryba stated the royal anthem is technically not being reintroduced, citing the provincial laws that has been all however ignored by different divisions in latest many years.
“It has all the time been a legislative requirement underneath the College Patriotic Observance Laws,” Gryba stated.
“Following the legislation is just not a matter of alternative for the board, as our oath of workplace requires us to uphold all laws.”
Gryba stated the choice stemmed from concern about different varieties of bulletins being made on the college previous to the singing of ‘O Canada,’ which led to a assessment of the laws round patriotic observances.
“This is a vital studying alternative for our college division and the broader neighborhood. The connection between Canada and the Crown is a constitutional actuality that’s typically under-addressed.
“College divisions are established by the Lieutenant Governor in Council and function throughout the constitutional framework of the Crown.”
As college trustees, he stated, the board members are required to pledge an oath to King Charles III.
The board, nonetheless, was stunned by the choice, based on trustee Scott Lynxleg, a vocal opponent of “God Save the King” in faculties.
“I requested for a vote on it they usually stated we couldn’t vote on it, it was a legislation and we couldn’t change the legislation — it’s a faculty board, we solely do coverage,” he stated.
“We speak about reconciliation, and now we’re pressured to hearken to a tune a couple of king … it simply doesn’t appear proper,” stated Lynxleg.
Schooling Minister Tracy Schmidt stated the division wouldn’t face any repercussions in the event that they, like each different college division within the province has for many years, opted to not play the tune.
“It’s nonetheless a rule that exists on the books. I believe most Manitobans would agree that that rule is outdated, it isn’t enforced in faculties — the division is just not imposing that rule.”
Schmidt says the province is in the midst of a broader assessment on schooling rules, together with the usage of anthems.
© 2025 International Information, a division of Corus Leisure Inc.
Source link